Looking for jewelry gift ideas that won’t feel like a last-minute gas station grab? You’re in the right place.
Jewelry is timeless, versatile, and — when chosen well — says I put actual thought into this. Whether it’s for a Valentine’s Day, Christmas, birthday, anniversary, holiday, or a random “I love your face” kind of moment, there’s a perfect piece of jewelry for every occasion and every relationship stage.
We’ve rounded up our favorite jewelry gift ideas that range from sweet and subtle to “whoa, did someone propose?” And don’t worry — we’ve broken it down by vibe so you can find something that fits your situation (awkward-new, getting-serious, or long-term legend).
Jewelry Gift Ideas for New Relationships
Not quite ready to drop three months’ salary? Cool. These pieces are sweet, stylish, and totally appropriate for early-stage romances, new flings, or when you’re just trying to charm without freaking them out.
Silver Anniversary Charm
If she already has a charm bracelet, this is the perfect addition. If she’s more of a necklace girl, this charm can be added to a chain. Either way, you can never go wrong with a pop of sparkle.
A sterling silver charm bracelet is a great gift for any occasion – her birthday, your anniversary, or a Valentine’s day, foone that she can build lots of special memories starting with you! Charms have never gone out of style, but over the last few years they are back in a big way!
Why I like it:
- Can be worn on a bracelet or necklace Perfect hint of sparkle
- Beautiful on its own or paired with other charms
Arrow Necklace
Cupid’s arrow might have struck you this past year! Send an arrow her way as well with a beautiful Arrow Necklace in sterling silver or Gold. Arrow motif is the latest take on the chevron/triangle trend, and it’s a fun way to tell a friend to follow your arrow.
Linear links like this tiny arrow link are perfect focal points for delicate, layered necklaces. The famous horizontal bar link gets an update in this gold-filled version. Texture it, stamp it or leave it as-is for a simple, understated look.
Leather Jewelry
If your budget is a little smaller and you just want to give a token leather gift, think about leather jewelry. A leather ring, anyone? That’s pretty unusual, stylish, and won’t break a bank. Bracelets, earrnings, necklaces – go wild. A classic leather anniversary gift.
See stylish handmade leather jewelry here
Have a bigger budget? Splurge a little. Designed & handmade in St-Barth Island, these leather accessories are made with real pearls and look incredible.
See luxury leather options here
Forged Iron Jewelry
You can’t go wrong with an anniversary jewelry gift. Lots of options to choose from – earrnings, necklaces, rings, keychains, bracelets, belt buckles, and more.
Moonstone Jewerly
Jewelry is a classic anniversary gift. There are lots of options featuring moonstones, so you’re bound to find something to fit every style. In fact, the simple bevel pendant caught my eye but there are also rings, pendants, necklaces, and so much more!
Birth Flower Earrings
Even the most astrology-obsessed among us knows their birthstone — but have you heard of birth flowers? These handmade earrings feature real botanicals tied to each birth month, with stems, petals, and leaves delicately preserved in lacquer and resin, then set in silver.
We love that it’s a more romantic, unexpected twist on the typical birth month gift. The look is timeless with a subtle nod to Victorian and gothic aesthetics — equal parts sentimental and stunning.
Romantic Candle & Keepsake Gift Box
This isn’t just a gift – it’s a whole mood. Inside this charming box: a lavender-vanilla candle with a heartfelt message, a handmade knitted rose that never wilts, a delicate infinity-heart necklace, and a wooden music box that plays a timeless tune. Thoughtful, cozy, and ready to give – no wrapping needed. Perfect for Valentine’s Day, anniversaries, or any moment you want her to feel seen, loved, and totally spoiled.
Personalized Wooden Jewelry Box
There’s something timeless about a beautiful jewelry box — especially one as elegant as this. Whether you’ve been gifting jewelry for years or they’ve built a collection of their own, this handcrafted Italian box is the perfect place to keep treasured pieces safe and beautifully displayed.
We love the classic wood inlay that complements any decor, and the best part? You can choose from over 150 tunes to make it sing — literally. A stunning, sentimental gift that’s as functional as it is meaningful.
Waterford Giftology Heart Box
It’s acceptable to wear your heart on your sleeve but it’s much cuter on her nightstand! This stunning trinket box is crafted from exquisite lead crystal and can be customized with both artwork and a special love note. The box is perfectly sized for slipping her wedding bands and earrings into before bed.
Why I like it:
- Functional but beautiful
- Great jewelry or trinket holder
- Custom options
Jewelry Gift Ideas for When Things Getting Serious
Things are heating up, the toothbrush is already at their place, and you want a gift that says “I’m into you” without saying “I bought us matching burial plots.” These picks strike the perfect balance.
Create Your Own Ring
Perhaps one of the more unusual gifts she could receive this year, but such a unique gift idea!
She’ll receive a ring-making kit in the mail, complete with everything she needs to design her ring. Once she’s created her masterpiece, she sends it back to the expert jewelers at Workbench London. They’ll then craft it according to her ring size, preferred metal, and preferred width. When she gets compliments on her unique ring, she’ll love telling everyone she designed it herself.
Meteorite Pendant Necklace
Got a sweetie who’s always looking to the stars? Grab them a piece of their own to keep next to their heart with a meteorite necklace. The meteorite in the necklace fell over 4,000 years ago and since it’s made of iron, you’re right in theme. This is sure to put stars in her eye. Each piece is one-of-a-kind. Authentic piece of meteorite that fell over 4,000 years ago
My Moon and Stars Necklace
As the saying goes, “You are my sun, my moon and all my stars”. What a beautiful way to convey your love with this personalized moon and stars necklace. This piece can be customized to your preference with up to 4 stars. My favorite option would be to choose three stars: one for each of your initials and a plus sign or heart in between. I personally like a shorter 18″ chain when wearing a delicate piece. She will adore the symbolism and thought put into this tasteful customized necklace.
Get it from GLDNxLayeredAndLong
Silky Knot Silver Bracelet
Even if they are not a huge jewelry fan, some anniversaries are simply made for gifting a piece of wearable art. A beautiful and simple sterling silver bracelet like this one is ideal for dressing up or a casual look. This one is unisex, and easy to dress up or down. Knotted design symbolizes lives joined together
Swarovski Crystal Fashion Jewelry
Set in both silver and gold plates, Swarovski has a variety of beautiful crystal pieces. From bold and dazzling to modest and chic, there is a style and piece to suit all tastes. The jewelry is fun and modern but also has some traditional styles too. The crystal colors are unusual and vivid which gives them a cool modern edge. Your love is sure to find something to exemplify her natural shine!
Why I like it:
- Nice setting options
- Some funky modern styles
- Stunning gemstone colors
Key to Your Love’s Heart Diamond Necklace
Another beautiful and symbolic option is a key to her heart necklace. This impressive James Allen diamond necklace features 66 brilliant white diamonds set in classic 14k yellow gold. My favorite twist that sets this piece apart from the rest is the tiny key placed slightly to the side of the lock. Delicate and luxurious, this is a necklace she will never take off. Show her that you would like to have her heart forever with this stunning gift.
Pinky Swear Necklace
Perhaps the most adorable on our list is this sweet little pinky swear necklace. A minimalist drawing of two hands making a pinky swear is a sweet symbolism of your promise to one another. I also love that this shop offers other gestures that you can add to create a charm necklace. Choose an “I love you” or hand heart to have as a thoughtful gift for future special occasions. I would personally be thrilled to receive this piece from a partner to add to my collection.
Select silver or gold for a timeless look, or rose gold for a more contemporary and stylish feeling.
Get it from GLDNxLayeredAndLong
Design Your Own Earrings
When in doubt, a new pair of earring are a great gift option. You can go with a classic design, or go for a set that has that special feeling that will ensure she will always remember the special day she opened them.
Diamond Stud Earrings: If this is a really special Valentine Day, step it up a notch and invest in a sparkly pair of diamond stud earrings. It will absolutely make her week! Pick from princess, round, asscher or cushion cuts ot create her very own one-of-a-kind pair of diamond stud earrings.
Hoop Earrings: Surprise her with a beautiful pair of Valentine’s Day hoop earrings that she can wear for any occasion.
Pearl Earrings: From stud or drops, gift your Valentine with a beautiful set of pearl earrings that she can dress up or down.
Better yet? Design your own earrnings! From start to finish, you make your own creation!
Birthstone Jewelry
Find a beautiful piece of jewelry in the color of her Birthstone. This piece will not only represent the month in which she was born, but becomes a beautiful piece that she can wear every day!
Jewelry Gift Ideas for Long-Term Love
You’ve weathered their snoring, weird snack habits, and questionable Netflix picks. Celebrate that enduring love with jewelry that actually means something — personalized, elevated, or heirloom-worthy.
Silver Locket
For an anniversary gifts that equal parts enchanting and functional, consider a locket. It’s a beautiful piece of jewelry your wife can wear every day and on special occasions, while also holding a picture of you both close to her heart.
Why I like it:
- A classic keepsake
- Keeps a photo close to their heart
- Floral design creates a vintage look
Infinity Heart Pendant
Another jewelry piece that made our list this year is this sterling silver heart-shaped pendant necklace by Blue Nile. I have a similar chain and heart pendant that I’ve worn around my neck for years and only take off to swim. This versatile little necklace will layer well with other chains and at 16-18” is the perfect length for almost any neckline. And bonus: it’s engravable! Most importantly, it will be a wonderful reminder of your connection and how much you love her.
Designer Earrings
When you’re looking for a gift that’s both meaningful and wearable, a delicate pair of earrings is always a win. Whether you choose matching styles for a group or pick something unique for each person based on their taste, it’s a subtle and beautiful way to show you care.
They’re small enough to wear every day, yet special enough to feel like a thoughtful keepsake. And best of all, they’re the kind of functional gift that won’t just sit in a drawer — they’ll be used, loved, and appreciated long after the occasion.
Birthstone Necklace
A slightly non-traditional gift — but one that feels incredibly personal.
Whether you’re marking the day you met, the month you married, or each other’s birthstones, a custom birthstone necklace is a beautiful way to carry a little piece of your love wherever you go. You can also include birthstones for children or family members, making it a perfect gift for growing or blended families. With plenty of design options to choose from, it’s a keepsake that’s as meaningful as it is timeless.
Cocktail Ring
Gemstone jewelry can often seem old fashion and come across extremely extravagant, but cocktail rings are more trendier pieces of jewelry to wear as a standout feature. Choose the gemstone based on her favorite color and watch as she lights up opening the ring box!
Satin Patina Gold Cuff Bracelet
This bracelet just screams “sexy little black dress.” It really does look like 14k gold satin, and the low-key hammered texture adds a layer of unique design beyond. Give it to her, then take her out for a night on the town and watch her shine.
Diamond Tennis Bracelet
A staple in any luxury jewellery box has to be the diamond tennis bracelet. As a timeless piece, the diamond tennis bracelet can be worn for any occasion, running an errand, for work meeting or formal events. This present will make her jewellery collection complete.
Eternity Ring
Eternity rings are typically set with an unbroken line of identically cut gemstones.
Eternity rings are generally expensive, and if you want to have one from a reputable online vendor, I’d recommend checking this seciton on Blue Nile or this section on James Allen. If you are on a tight budget, that you can get great rings on Amazon for under $20!!! Just be sure to select one that has a lot of positive reviews. This link will take you to the page that shows the top 50 ranking ethernity rings on Amazong now.
Show her the symbol of lasting affection with a beautiful eternity ring!
Now that we’ve given you some options to consider, which piece of jewelry will show your love this Valentine’s Day 2020? Whether you select a symbolic pendant, set of heart-shaped earrings, or a luxurious diamond ring, we think she will love the care and consideration you put into your final choice. But most of all, she will appreciate how much you love and care about her.
Leave a Reply